Is peaceful protesting the answer anymore?
I’m a great believer in protesting, and abhor people who can sit and moan about the world in internet forums but never actually get out and do something about it, even if that ‘something’is simply adding their name to a petition or writing to their MP. If I see something I feel is unjust, I want to do something about it. If I’m angry enough I will help to draw attention to the issue by going on marches and rallies (and I’ll also sign that petition, attend meetings, help with organisation, whatever it takes).
In the 80s I would go along with my mum to various anti-nuclear protests and actions. They were always peaceful, non-violent protests. But we did cause inconvenience to the police, the MoD and the government and gave journalists something to focus on, using civil disobedience. It might not sound very revolutionary or exciting, but lying down in a main highway and linking arms with fellow protestors, playing dead when the police tried to pick you up, caused absolute chaos. They’d lost control of us.
Thatcher brought in laws around protests and made it illegal to congregate without a permit from the police and the local council. So now you have to plan it with the authorities for months, negotiate with them and abide by whatever rules they give you. They will tell you when you can march, which roads you may march down, what time you can hold a rally, and when it must all be over by so that normal life can resume. In other words they will allow you to protest, but don’t make a scene and don’t disrupt anything.
Which makes it all the more important to make a scene and disrupt things.
Take the anti-Iraq War demonstration… we all did what we were allowed to do, had a lovely day, and went home. The media was full of lovely images of hundreds of thousands of people making their way to Hyde Park that day. It was an incredible experience to be there. The idealogical side of me grew excited and thought that a government couldn’t possibly ignore this many people. We all know how that turned out. A week later and the protest was forgotten and the government carried on with their plans. For the first time I truly realised what I had suspected all along – that no one was listening.
Yesterday I was in London for the TUC March for the Alternative. I was there to swell numbers and draw attention to what that alternative to the cuts is. Tax the rich. Make the bankers responsible. Look at http://robinhoodtax.org/ for the alternative. I marched for my colleagues jobs, that I, as their union rep, am trying to save. I marched for my own job too, frankly. I marched for our students who have lost their EMA, their travel passes, and will have to pay through the nse for university education our politicians took for granted (and for free). I marched for pension rights. I marched for our NHS, our youth centres, our libraries. We marched when and where we were told, and it was a brilliant day. News started to filter through about trouble in Picadilly… paint bombs and broken windows. Instantly, we knew hat the media would be focussing on. Not the thousands who marched peacefully, made their point and went home happy, but the minority of ‘mindless thugs’.
Are they mindless thugs though? As we walked back towards Euston through the same route as we’d passed on our way through, we saw paint strewn windows, a few smashed windows, and occupations. No violence though. Just angry people who are fed up and who want to draw attention to tax avoidance. The paint is soluble and will wash off. With the amount of tax these companies are saving, they can afford to replace a couple of windows.
The point is, the media will run with this now, and the question of tax avoidance will stay in the headlines. The protestors are clever and always one step ahead of the police, and they play the game well. I’m amazed at our students’ ability to plan and execute, then disperse and reform at another location to do it all again. They leave the authorities with no control, so they eventually use batons on our young people. And let’s get beyond the headlines – these are not violent people. But we saw ourselves the police lining up in riot gear before anything had happened, almost willing the trouble to begin. Even as a 40-odd year old parent, I had an odd compulsion to have a go when I was faced with lines of police intimidating me. And we’re paying for those polce with our taxes. I’d rather they were out there fighting real crime, rather than doing the government’s work for them by trying to suppress the freedom of speech.
You might not find me standing on top of Nelson’s column or occupying Top Shop, but I do think that buildings and ‘stuff’ is fair game in the bigger picture. The more chaos we can cause as protestors, the better.